Loading...

Zaya Cocobana 16-Year rum
Zaya Cocobana 16-Year review posted 2 months ago by Mo McGurk 🇺🇸 | 281 ratings

The bottle hints there are added spices and flavors, but if they are there, they were subtle to me. There is a suggestion of a chocolate flavored pipe tobacco I once enjoyed. That memory brought a smile, and bumped the rating up to almost a 6. 

Wright & Brown Barrel Aged rum
Wright & Brown Barrel Aged review posted 2 months ago by Mo McGurk 🇺🇸 | 281 ratings

Nice oaky flavor straight, but strong. I suspect a few more years aging would mellow it. Mixed was not as good, and the oak did not come out as much.

Bombarda Falconet (Black Bottle) 8-Year rum
Bombarda Falconet (Black Bottle) 8-Year review posted 2 months ago by Mo McGurk 🇺🇸 | 281 ratings

Better than the Bombarda Culverin by three years. More oaky in flavor, but the burn remains. Bottle remains pretty cool.


Hamilton Lost Voyage rum
Hamilton Lost Voyage review posted 2 months ago by Mo McGurk 🇺🇸 | 281 ratings

Bought this one twice, a year apart. First time, it had the usual nice molasses flavor that I have come to expect from Hamiltons. The second time, the molasses was very, very faint, which was a bit disappointing. Some burn straight, and okay mixed.

Kuleana Agricole rum
Kuleana Agricole review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

This is the only white rum I own and I use it almost exclusively in mojitos. It's really quite good for that.

Kuleana Hokulei rum
Kuleana Hokulei review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

This rum is a pretty ambitious blend of no less than four molasses rums, two body rums and an additional accent rum. I can definitely taste the vanilla and the dark semi-sweet chocolate, but nothing of the espresso as presented on the website. My wife gave me two Kuleana rums for my birthday last year. It's not bad on its own, but I prefer to use this one in mixed drinks.

Foursquare 2007 12-Year rum
Foursquare 2007 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by ripperussr 🇨🇿 | 659 ratings

Fruity, wood and vanilla in body; fruits, raisins, caramel and biting body; bitter long tail.

Trois Rivieres Cuvée Bois d'Inde rum
Trois Rivieres Cuvée Bois d'Inde review posted 2 months ago by ripperussr 🇨🇿 | 659 ratings

Fruits, flowers, pear, herbs and spices in aroma; grass, technical notes, spices, wood in body; shorter tail.

Warehouse #1 Overproof Unaged White WPE rum
Warehouse #1 Overproof Unaged White WPE review posted 2 months ago by ripperussr 🇨🇿 | 659 ratings

Thinner, riped banana, pineapple in aroma; sweet start, smooth light body, sugarcane, honey, flower, fruits, charcoal in the end of the body; pleasant fruity tail

Mount Gay XO Triple Cask rum
Mount Gay XO Triple Cask review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

Intensely complex - floral, citrus, spice, chocolate on the first sip. Apricots, dates, plums and spiced apple the next. This rum's pretty amazing. I plan to sit on this one a bit longer and come back to it.

Flor de Caña 18-Year rum
Flor de Caña 18-Year review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

I gravitated towards this rum based on its recognizably large presence on the top shelf in every one of Disney's cruise ship bars. It's one of their staples and I find that it goes down just as smooth neat as it does with ice (but I prefer the former).

It has some faint floral notes, but I mostly catch caramel, cranberries, sweet cocoa and ginger. It's best to let this one settle for a few minutes before partaking.

A. H. Riise Non Plus Ultra Black edition rum
A. H. Riise Non Plus Ultra Black edition review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

I purchased this in Amsterdam on the recommendation of the AH Riise sales rep. It's purely awful. I'm sure that, at its base, it's rum in some form, but overloaded with vanilla and licorice flavorings. Not at all worth the 79,00 Euros I paid for it and definitely not worth all the effort I went through to find it and buy it.

Rhum JM XO 6-Year rum
Rhum JM XO 6-Year review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

So much oak in the nose that I gave it away. Vinegar bite and charcoal burn.

Doorly's XO 6-Year rum
Doorly's XO 6-Year review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

Haven't opened yet, but adding this to my cabinet to review in detail later.

Clairin Communal rum
Clairin Communal review posted 2 months ago by TheJayHawk 🇺🇸 | 104 ratings

Aroma - tutti frutti toothpaste followed by grass, vanilla candle, and blueberry muffin

Taste - sugar cookie followed by basil, leather, and a charcoal finish

Clairin Vaval rum
Clairin Vaval review posted 2 months ago by TheJayHawk 🇺🇸 | 104 ratings

Aroma - overripe pineapple followed by kiwi, herbal tea, and nail polish remover

Taste - fresh mango followed by cucumber, allspice, and a volcanic soil finish

Montanya Exclusiva rum
Montanya Exclusiva review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

This local Colorado distillery is doing a great job in producing such a high-quality rum with only a three year aging process. The local port barrel finish is much to my liking as it sweetens things up a bit and keeps things more sustainable.

Notes of fresh raspberries, strawberries and ginger. It's like smelling a fistful of fresh earth after a sugar beet harvest (also a well known Colorado thing).

Ron Zacapa Edicion Negra rum
Ron Zacapa Edicion Negra review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

This was another Duty Free acquisition while traveling outside of the United States. I picked it up in Costa Maya for about $40 so it seemed like a good purchase. I think it will be fine to use in a rum punch or something like that, but it's not appealing to sip neat. Pretty standard vanilla notes with sharp after burn.

Black Tot Master Blender's Reserve 2022 Edition rum
Black Tot Master Blender's Reserve 2022 Edition review posted 2 months ago by ripperussr 🇨🇿 | 659 ratings

Dark chocolate, orange zest, cinnamon, hazelnut and tropical fruits in aroma; milk chocolate, raisins, coffee, riped banana, anise, butter and caramel in body; nutmeg, cocoa, cinnamon in pepper in long heating tail.

Botran Rare Blend Vintage French Wine Cask rum
Botran Rare Blend Vintage French Wine Cask review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

I suppose it's possible that this rum had already turned before I bought it. It was an impulse buy at the Heathrow Duty Free shop. The substance in this bottle reeked of turpentine and bad merlot. I gifted it to a Verizon tech who really liked the looks of the bottle when he had stopped by to fix our internet.

Seven Fathoms Premium rum
Seven Fathoms Premium review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

A gently rocking barrel under pressure at a depth of 42 feet below sea level sounds interesting, but I don't see where isolating a cask of rum from the air above could possibly do anything to improve the flavor. In my opinion, it doesn't. It's a gimmicky aging process that leaves the rum thin and oakish.

Kirkland Spiced rum
Kirkland Spiced review posted 2 months ago by sporefrog 🇺🇸 | 66 ratings

It's probably just repackaged Cruzan Spiced, but when you've puked something up before you tend to not give it any benefits of doubt.

Black Tot Master Blender's Reserve 2022 Edition rum
Black Tot Master Blender's Reserve 2022 Edition review posted 2 months ago by dakob 🇨🇿 | 206 ratings

Dark chocolate, mocha, roasted fruit, and wood aroma. Heavy palate with dark chocolate, smoke, tropical fruit, and spice. Long, warming finish.

Kirk and Sweeney Gran Reserva rum
Kirk and Sweeney Gran Reserva review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

This was my first bottle of K&S and the most I had ever spent on a bottle of rum when I bought it. I was sorely disappointed. Oak upon oak with a side of dry, offending oak. This became last year's white elephant gift at the company holiday party. The scotch fan that took it home was happy.

Cruzan Single Barrel rum
Cruzan Single Barrel review posted 2 months ago by sporefrog 🇺🇸 | 66 ratings

Nose: Orange peel, vanilla, hint of medicinal note.
Palette: Slightly thin but mellow, primarily oak.
Finish: Long finish of cream and butter with no ethanol or aftertaste.

If you like a woody rum, this is for you. Certainly no sugar here. About worth the price.

Edit: The one-note element of this rum has led me to treat it more as a high-end mixer rather than a low-end sipper. I still recommend it.

Zaya Cocobana 16-Year rum
Zaya Cocobana 16-Year review posted 2 months ago by Mo McGurk 🇺🇸 | 281 ratings

The bottle hints there are added spices and flavors, but if they are there, they were subtle to me. There is a suggestion of a chocolate flavored pipe tobacco I once enjoyed. That memory brought a smile, and bumped the rating up to almost a 6. 

Wright & Brown Barrel Aged rum
Wright & Brown Barrel Aged review posted 2 months ago by Mo McGurk 🇺🇸 | 281 ratings

Nice oaky flavor straight, but strong. I suspect a few more years aging would mellow it. Mixed was not as good, and the oak did not come out as much.

Bombarda Falconet (Black Bottle) 8-Year rum
Bombarda Falconet (Black Bottle) 8-Year review posted 2 months ago by Mo McGurk 🇺🇸 | 281 ratings

Better than the Bombarda Culverin by three years. More oaky in flavor, but the burn remains. Bottle remains pretty cool.


Hamilton Lost Voyage rum
Hamilton Lost Voyage review posted 2 months ago by Mo McGurk 🇺🇸 | 281 ratings

Bought this one twice, a year apart. First time, it had the usual nice molasses flavor that I have come to expect from Hamiltons. The second time, the molasses was very, very faint, which was a bit disappointing. Some burn straight, and okay mixed.

Kuleana Agricole rum
Kuleana Agricole review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

This is the only white rum I own and I use it almost exclusively in mojitos. It's really quite good for that.

Kuleana Hokulei rum
Kuleana Hokulei review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

This rum is a pretty ambitious blend of no less than four molasses rums, two body rums and an additional accent rum. I can definitely taste the vanilla and the dark semi-sweet chocolate, but nothing of the espresso as presented on the website. My wife gave me two Kuleana rums for my birthday last year. It's not bad on its own, but I prefer to use this one in mixed drinks.

Foursquare 2007 12-Year rum
Foursquare 2007 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by ripperussr 🇨🇿 | 659 ratings

Fruity, wood and vanilla in body; fruits, raisins, caramel and biting body; bitter long tail.

Trois Rivieres Cuvée Bois d'Inde rum
Trois Rivieres Cuvée Bois d'Inde review posted 2 months ago by ripperussr 🇨🇿 | 659 ratings

Fruits, flowers, pear, herbs and spices in aroma; grass, technical notes, spices, wood in body; shorter tail.

Warehouse #1 Overproof Unaged White WPE rum
Warehouse #1 Overproof Unaged White WPE review posted 2 months ago by ripperussr 🇨🇿 | 659 ratings

Thinner, riped banana, pineapple in aroma; sweet start, smooth light body, sugarcane, honey, flower, fruits, charcoal in the end of the body; pleasant fruity tail

Mount Gay XO Triple Cask rum
Mount Gay XO Triple Cask review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

Intensely complex - floral, citrus, spice, chocolate on the first sip. Apricots, dates, plums and spiced apple the next. This rum's pretty amazing. I plan to sit on this one a bit longer and come back to it.

Flor de Caña 18-Year rum
Flor de Caña 18-Year review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

I gravitated towards this rum based on its recognizably large presence on the top shelf in every one of Disney's cruise ship bars. It's one of their staples and I find that it goes down just as smooth neat as it does with ice (but I prefer the former).

It has some faint floral notes, but I mostly catch caramel, cranberries, sweet cocoa and ginger. It's best to let this one settle for a few minutes before partaking.

A. H. Riise Non Plus Ultra Black edition rum
A. H. Riise Non Plus Ultra Black edition review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

I purchased this in Amsterdam on the recommendation of the AH Riise sales rep. It's purely awful. I'm sure that, at its base, it's rum in some form, but overloaded with vanilla and licorice flavorings. Not at all worth the 79,00 Euros I paid for it and definitely not worth all the effort I went through to find it and buy it.

Rhum JM XO 6-Year rum
Rhum JM XO 6-Year review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

So much oak in the nose that I gave it away. Vinegar bite and charcoal burn.

Doorly's XO 6-Year rum
Doorly's XO 6-Year review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

Haven't opened yet, but adding this to my cabinet to review in detail later.

Clairin Communal rum
Clairin Communal review posted 2 months ago by TheJayHawk 🇺🇸 | 104 ratings

Aroma - tutti frutti toothpaste followed by grass, vanilla candle, and blueberry muffin

Taste - sugar cookie followed by basil, leather, and a charcoal finish

Clairin Vaval rum
Clairin Vaval review posted 2 months ago by TheJayHawk 🇺🇸 | 104 ratings

Aroma - overripe pineapple followed by kiwi, herbal tea, and nail polish remover

Taste - fresh mango followed by cucumber, allspice, and a volcanic soil finish

Montanya Exclusiva rum
Montanya Exclusiva review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

This local Colorado distillery is doing a great job in producing such a high-quality rum with only a three year aging process. The local port barrel finish is much to my liking as it sweetens things up a bit and keeps things more sustainable.

Notes of fresh raspberries, strawberries and ginger. It's like smelling a fistful of fresh earth after a sugar beet harvest (also a well known Colorado thing).

Ron Zacapa Edicion Negra rum
Ron Zacapa Edicion Negra review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

This was another Duty Free acquisition while traveling outside of the United States. I picked it up in Costa Maya for about $40 so it seemed like a good purchase. I think it will be fine to use in a rum punch or something like that, but it's not appealing to sip neat. Pretty standard vanilla notes with sharp after burn.

Black Tot Master Blender's Reserve 2022 Edition rum
Black Tot Master Blender's Reserve 2022 Edition review posted 2 months ago by ripperussr 🇨🇿 | 659 ratings

Dark chocolate, orange zest, cinnamon, hazelnut and tropical fruits in aroma; milk chocolate, raisins, coffee, riped banana, anise, butter and caramel in body; nutmeg, cocoa, cinnamon in pepper in long heating tail.

Botran Rare Blend Vintage French Wine Cask rum
Botran Rare Blend Vintage French Wine Cask review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

I suppose it's possible that this rum had already turned before I bought it. It was an impulse buy at the Heathrow Duty Free shop. The substance in this bottle reeked of turpentine and bad merlot. I gifted it to a Verizon tech who really liked the looks of the bottle when he had stopped by to fix our internet.

Seven Fathoms Premium rum
Seven Fathoms Premium review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

A gently rocking barrel under pressure at a depth of 42 feet below sea level sounds interesting, but I don't see where isolating a cask of rum from the air above could possibly do anything to improve the flavor. In my opinion, it doesn't. It's a gimmicky aging process that leaves the rum thin and oakish.

Kirkland Spiced rum
Kirkland Spiced review posted 2 months ago by sporefrog 🇺🇸 | 66 ratings

It's probably just repackaged Cruzan Spiced, but when you've puked something up before you tend to not give it any benefits of doubt.

Black Tot Master Blender's Reserve 2022 Edition rum
Black Tot Master Blender's Reserve 2022 Edition review posted 2 months ago by dakob 🇨🇿 | 206 ratings

Dark chocolate, mocha, roasted fruit, and wood aroma. Heavy palate with dark chocolate, smoke, tropical fruit, and spice. Long, warming finish.

Kirk and Sweeney Gran Reserva rum
Kirk and Sweeney Gran Reserva review posted 2 months ago by Boulderado 🇺🇸 | 24 ratings

This was my first bottle of K&S and the most I had ever spent on a bottle of rum when I bought it. I was sorely disappointed. Oak upon oak with a side of dry, offending oak. This became last year's white elephant gift at the company holiday party. The scotch fan that took it home was happy.

Cruzan Single Barrel rum
Cruzan Single Barrel review posted 2 months ago by sporefrog 🇺🇸 | 66 ratings

Nose: Orange peel, vanilla, hint of medicinal note.
Palette: Slightly thin but mellow, primarily oak.
Finish: Long finish of cream and butter with no ethanol or aftertaste.

If you like a woody rum, this is for you. Certainly no sugar here. About worth the price.

Edit: The one-note element of this rum has led me to treat it more as a high-end mixer rather than a low-end sipper. I still recommend it.

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...