Loading...

Privateer Navy Yard Barrel Proof rum
Privateer Navy Yard Barrel Proof review posted 3 months ago by Jobu 🇺🇸 | 12 ratings

Really nice and complex. Rich dark and spicy. Not too sweet. Love that it’s made locally.

Abuelo Three Angels 12-Year rum
Abuelo Three Angels 12-Year review posted 3 months ago by Pipestone 🇸🇰 | 64 ratings

Intense aroma, sweet,rich multilayer taste.
12 years rum from Panama , found on my trip. I glad I bougt it.

Plantation Barbados 5-Year rum
Plantation Barbados 5-Year review posted 3 months ago by MichielvdZee 🇳🇱 | 2 ratings

My second real rum I have tasted and it is an improvement. Smooth, good aromas and really enjoyable when mixed with cola.


Mount Gay Eclipse rum
Mount Gay Eclipse review posted 3 months ago by MichielvdZee 🇳🇱 | 2 ratings

Disclaimer: First "real" rum I tried so I'm new to identifying the different aromas.

Tastes good mixed with cola and it's really affordable as I purchased for only €19.95. Tried it as a sipper but it initially hit me with the alcohol scent and taste.

Volbeat III 15-Year rum
Volbeat III 15-Year review posted 3 months ago by Laszlo 🇩🇪 | 34 ratings

I like the band so I was really curious how this rum will taste. And in the end: disappointment.
The rum is not bad, sweet taste with oaky and fruity notes, but according to the score here, I was expecting something more special. In the end it is nothing just an overpriced band merch.

Plantation 3 Stars Artisanal rum
Plantation 3 Stars Artisanal review posted 3 months ago by PTGarcia 🇺🇸 | 38 ratings

I know sugar is added to this one, but I could not stop drinking classic daiquiris with this. Great as a mixer with excellent price point.

Enjoy!

Mount Gay XO Triple Cask rum
Mount Gay XO Triple Cask review posted 3 months ago by sporefrog 🇺🇸 | 66 ratings

An absolutely delicious rum for every occasion. A+. Too bad there's so much competition now at its current price point.

Yolo Gold 10-Year rum
Yolo Gold 10-Year review posted 3 months ago by sporefrog 🇺🇸 | 66 ratings

With no additives, vanilla ice cream in a glass. No pretention here. YOLO.

El Dorado 5-Year rum
El Dorado 5-Year review posted 3 months ago by CaptainGreen (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 104 ratings

Arrgh! This be a somewhat disappointing rum. On the nose, there be oak and butterscotch in a thick, buttery way, but there also be a hint of sweetness from some fruit that - fetch me up for daft - I cannot identify. There also be a leathery aroma that shows up at the very end, like findin’ out someone has a leather kink about them AFTER you set sail from port and they be asking about cabin boy "positions". On the tongue, she not be sweet, but she not be not sweet either. That first hit on the tongue be as clear and empty as a blue sky in spring. Aye, there be a hint of sweet, but it be like drinkin’ sweet water, not rum. A flurry of flavors attack shortly after that, but none of them be enjoyable, and none of them stay long enough to sort out. There be barely a burn, but nothin’ worth talkin' about. Aye, there be no afterglow with this rum. Ya pay the lady and she be gone like the darkness at dawn - all quick like. I have a 5-year-old powder monkey doin' a better job than this 5-year-old rum. Might this rum be good for sippin’? No. Might this be the worst rum ever? No. There be rums more suitable for cleaning sword wounds, but this rum be just above that. Barely. Might this run be better added to somethin’ else? That not be an option, mate. Get off my ship! Arrgh!

Ron Zacapa 2015 Reserva Limitada rum
Ron Zacapa 2015 Reserva Limitada review posted 3 months ago by ripperussr 🇨🇿 | 659 ratings

Caramel, vanilla, spices (cinnamon, glove), raisins and berries in aroma; sweet caramel, bitter grapes, raisins, chocolate, vanilla and oak in body; warming sherry tail.

Hamilton Puesto rum
Hamilton Puesto review posted 3 months ago by Bitbeard 🇺🇸 | 48 ratings

A nice blend of rums. Sweet, funky, and bitter edge. When adding a mint leaf, it fits perfectly. Seems like it will hit the mark for a mojito.

Hamilton Puesto rum
Hamilton Puesto review posted 3 months ago by revsteph (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 421 ratings

Tasted July 7 2024, courtesy of the Forbidden Hole stash.
Appearance: clear
Aroma: pine
Flavor: brown sugar and pineapple
Notes : a bit hot, with not much aftertaste. This rum seems bitter, rather than sweet. The label indicates this was blended specifically for mojitos, so one wonders if this is to compensate for the sweet and mint of the mojito.
7 rating because I'm not quite sure what to do with this rum

Hamilton Puesto rum
Hamilton Puesto review posted 3 months ago by Cool Breeze (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 663 ratings

Bottle purchased from The Bottle Shop in South Park San Diego for $14. Tasted on 7-7-24. Pours clear. Aroma is a faint blend of bubble gum and model car glue. Flavor really grows on you. A beer hop bitterness settles over the sides of your tongue. Oddly pleasant to drink neat, I can’t wait to make mojitos with this as I can see how it would balance out.

Cihuatan Indigo 8-Year rum
Cihuatan Indigo 8-Year review posted at Laka Lono Rum Club 3 months ago by Bitbeard 🇺🇸 | 48 ratings

A slight bitter edge to a rich sweet rum. Maple syrup, brown sugar, ethanol heat, with spicy finish

Muddy River Basil rum
Muddy River Basil review posted 3 months ago by Jessieh 🇺🇸 | 4 ratings

Such a great local Rum! North Carolina Rum and North Carolina Basil to make a beautiful product!

Muddy River Coconut rum
Muddy River Coconut review posted 3 months ago by Jessieh 🇺🇸 | 4 ratings

What Coconut Rum should taste like! A perfect pairing of flavor and proof.

Plantation Pineapple Stiggin's Fancy rum
Plantation Pineapple Stiggin's Fancy review posted 3 months ago by DesT9656 🇨🇦 | 134 ratings

I saw the reviews and the 7 rating, that suggests to me it is a weak sipper, but hoped you were all wrong. I wanted this to be my summer go to sipper and its not. Can it be sipped neat - yes but with a bit of bite in the nose, on the tongue and the throat. its not clearing my sinuses but that alcohol is not hiding itself. Only mixing was with Sprite which improved the flavor overall. Cheers.

Sammys Beach Bar Kola Nut rum
Sammys Beach Bar Kola Nut review posted 3 months ago by DesT9656 🇨🇦 | 134 ratings

Stumbled into a store doing a bunch of samples and this was one of them. Smell is vanilla forward, taste is spice and coffee forward. Taste was a bit umami probably from the Kola nut (what ever that is) and had a hazelnut vibe to it. Here is the cool part. I had the first sample neat then had with coke and the coke turned the sample into cherry coke. Totally off the chart taste experience. Not a harsh finish and can easily sip. 35% ABV from Sammy Haggar and Rick Springfield. Cheers.

Don Papa Small Batch rum
Don Papa Small Batch review posted 3 months ago by Heliski Agent (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 13 ratings

Hardly touched. Not even sure I'd make a cuba libre with this one. How is it on stains?

Plantation XO 20th Anniversary rum
Plantation XO 20th Anniversary review posted 3 months ago by Heliski Agent (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 13 ratings

Love it. Rich and robust. May be my favorite so far.

The Salford Rum Company Spiced rum
The Salford Rum Company Spiced review posted 3 months ago by JRoberts95 🇪🇸 | 55 ratings

Have tried several spiced rums from smaller U.K. distilleries, this is definitely up there. Nice colour and smell, does feel very artificially sweet at times, but a has a great flavour. Would recommend to to anyone looking for a U.K. rum. Bottle is a belter as well

Plantation Barbados Grande Reserve rum
Plantation Barbados Grande Reserve review posted 3 months ago by Administrator 🇸🇰 | 40 ratings

Not bad. The taste is dry with a hint of oak, not very sweet and a little bit like orange peels. Maybe it is better for mixed drinks. Light amber color.
Bottle is classic Plantation style, very nice with the cork.

Rum&Cane Central America XO Rum 6-Year rum
Rum&Cane Central America XO Rum 6-Year review posted 3 months ago by Bonandy 🇵🇱 | 116 ratings

Another bottle of Rum & Cane. A blend of rums from Guatemala and Nicaragua. Light amber color. Slightly sweet. Toffee and vanilla aroma. Perceptible alcohol strength 43%

Don Papa Baroko 3-Year rum
Don Papa Baroko 3-Year review posted 3 months ago by LUKAŽIGA 🇸🇮 | 263 ratings

6,9:The nose is very sweet, orange and vanilla. Like an oriental confection, the rum caresses the nostrils with a pinch of powdered sugar. One might think of a strawberry- or rosewater-flavored Turkish delight. The candied orange peel still contains some of its slightly bitter oil, which adds a little more depth.
Aeration confirms and reinforces the sensation of roundness. The candy sugar is melted and takes on the air of barley sugar. It's also reminiscent of the first bite of strawberry gum.
7:The palate is soft, fluid and quite sweet. The confectionery and bubblegum ambience remains, though one might have expected a stickier texture. The vanilla glides slowly over the tongue, the orange is in tune and forgets any hint of bitterness. On the other hand, a slight spicy, peppery note lifts the whole.
6,2:The finish is very sweet, with strawberry, banana and orange in confectionery form.

Plantation Xaymaca Special Dry rum
Plantation Xaymaca Special Dry review posted 3 months ago by Michael Norell 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

...than this rum. I can hardly believe there could be such a variation in ratings as on this rum, and maybe, just maybe it is like cilantro? Just genetically, perhaps some of us are wired to taste something grizzly where others taste something delightful. But I can honestly say I've never tasted any rum so "medicinal" as this. I have had good-tasting Plantation Rum in the past (I don't remember which variation), but this Xaymaca is truly awful to my own taste-buds.

Privateer Navy Yard Barrel Proof rum
Privateer Navy Yard Barrel Proof review posted 3 months ago by Jobu 🇺🇸 | 12 ratings

Really nice and complex. Rich dark and spicy. Not too sweet. Love that it’s made locally.

Abuelo Three Angels 12-Year rum
Abuelo Three Angels 12-Year review posted 3 months ago by Pipestone 🇸🇰 | 64 ratings

Intense aroma, sweet,rich multilayer taste.
12 years rum from Panama , found on my trip. I glad I bougt it.

Plantation Barbados 5-Year rum
Plantation Barbados 5-Year review posted 3 months ago by MichielvdZee 🇳🇱 | 2 ratings

My second real rum I have tasted and it is an improvement. Smooth, good aromas and really enjoyable when mixed with cola.


Mount Gay Eclipse rum
Mount Gay Eclipse review posted 3 months ago by MichielvdZee 🇳🇱 | 2 ratings

Disclaimer: First "real" rum I tried so I'm new to identifying the different aromas.

Tastes good mixed with cola and it's really affordable as I purchased for only €19.95. Tried it as a sipper but it initially hit me with the alcohol scent and taste.

Volbeat III 15-Year rum
Volbeat III 15-Year review posted 3 months ago by Laszlo 🇩🇪 | 34 ratings

I like the band so I was really curious how this rum will taste. And in the end: disappointment.
The rum is not bad, sweet taste with oaky and fruity notes, but according to the score here, I was expecting something more special. In the end it is nothing just an overpriced band merch.

Plantation 3 Stars Artisanal rum
Plantation 3 Stars Artisanal review posted 3 months ago by PTGarcia 🇺🇸 | 38 ratings

I know sugar is added to this one, but I could not stop drinking classic daiquiris with this. Great as a mixer with excellent price point.

Enjoy!

Mount Gay XO Triple Cask rum
Mount Gay XO Triple Cask review posted 3 months ago by sporefrog 🇺🇸 | 66 ratings

An absolutely delicious rum for every occasion. A+. Too bad there's so much competition now at its current price point.

Yolo Gold 10-Year rum
Yolo Gold 10-Year review posted 3 months ago by sporefrog 🇺🇸 | 66 ratings

With no additives, vanilla ice cream in a glass. No pretention here. YOLO.

El Dorado 5-Year rum
El Dorado 5-Year review posted 3 months ago by CaptainGreen (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 104 ratings

Arrgh! This be a somewhat disappointing rum. On the nose, there be oak and butterscotch in a thick, buttery way, but there also be a hint of sweetness from some fruit that - fetch me up for daft - I cannot identify. There also be a leathery aroma that shows up at the very end, like findin’ out someone has a leather kink about them AFTER you set sail from port and they be asking about cabin boy "positions". On the tongue, she not be sweet, but she not be not sweet either. That first hit on the tongue be as clear and empty as a blue sky in spring. Aye, there be a hint of sweet, but it be like drinkin’ sweet water, not rum. A flurry of flavors attack shortly after that, but none of them be enjoyable, and none of them stay long enough to sort out. There be barely a burn, but nothin’ worth talkin' about. Aye, there be no afterglow with this rum. Ya pay the lady and she be gone like the darkness at dawn - all quick like. I have a 5-year-old powder monkey doin' a better job than this 5-year-old rum. Might this rum be good for sippin’? No. Might this be the worst rum ever? No. There be rums more suitable for cleaning sword wounds, but this rum be just above that. Barely. Might this run be better added to somethin’ else? That not be an option, mate. Get off my ship! Arrgh!

Ron Zacapa 2015 Reserva Limitada rum
Ron Zacapa 2015 Reserva Limitada review posted 3 months ago by ripperussr 🇨🇿 | 659 ratings

Caramel, vanilla, spices (cinnamon, glove), raisins and berries in aroma; sweet caramel, bitter grapes, raisins, chocolate, vanilla and oak in body; warming sherry tail.

Hamilton Puesto rum
Hamilton Puesto review posted 3 months ago by Bitbeard 🇺🇸 | 48 ratings

A nice blend of rums. Sweet, funky, and bitter edge. When adding a mint leaf, it fits perfectly. Seems like it will hit the mark for a mojito.

Hamilton Puesto rum
Hamilton Puesto review posted 3 months ago by revsteph (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 421 ratings

Tasted July 7 2024, courtesy of the Forbidden Hole stash.
Appearance: clear
Aroma: pine
Flavor: brown sugar and pineapple
Notes : a bit hot, with not much aftertaste. This rum seems bitter, rather than sweet. The label indicates this was blended specifically for mojitos, so one wonders if this is to compensate for the sweet and mint of the mojito.
7 rating because I'm not quite sure what to do with this rum

Hamilton Puesto rum
Hamilton Puesto review posted 3 months ago by Cool Breeze (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 663 ratings

Bottle purchased from The Bottle Shop in South Park San Diego for $14. Tasted on 7-7-24. Pours clear. Aroma is a faint blend of bubble gum and model car glue. Flavor really grows on you. A beer hop bitterness settles over the sides of your tongue. Oddly pleasant to drink neat, I can’t wait to make mojitos with this as I can see how it would balance out.

Cihuatan Indigo 8-Year rum
Cihuatan Indigo 8-Year review posted at Laka Lono Rum Club 3 months ago by Bitbeard 🇺🇸 | 48 ratings

A slight bitter edge to a rich sweet rum. Maple syrup, brown sugar, ethanol heat, with spicy finish

Muddy River Basil rum
Muddy River Basil review posted 3 months ago by Jessieh 🇺🇸 | 4 ratings

Such a great local Rum! North Carolina Rum and North Carolina Basil to make a beautiful product!

Muddy River Coconut rum
Muddy River Coconut review posted 3 months ago by Jessieh 🇺🇸 | 4 ratings

What Coconut Rum should taste like! A perfect pairing of flavor and proof.

Plantation Pineapple Stiggin's Fancy rum
Plantation Pineapple Stiggin's Fancy review posted 3 months ago by DesT9656 🇨🇦 | 134 ratings

I saw the reviews and the 7 rating, that suggests to me it is a weak sipper, but hoped you were all wrong. I wanted this to be my summer go to sipper and its not. Can it be sipped neat - yes but with a bit of bite in the nose, on the tongue and the throat. its not clearing my sinuses but that alcohol is not hiding itself. Only mixing was with Sprite which improved the flavor overall. Cheers.

Sammys Beach Bar Kola Nut rum
Sammys Beach Bar Kola Nut review posted 3 months ago by DesT9656 🇨🇦 | 134 ratings

Stumbled into a store doing a bunch of samples and this was one of them. Smell is vanilla forward, taste is spice and coffee forward. Taste was a bit umami probably from the Kola nut (what ever that is) and had a hazelnut vibe to it. Here is the cool part. I had the first sample neat then had with coke and the coke turned the sample into cherry coke. Totally off the chart taste experience. Not a harsh finish and can easily sip. 35% ABV from Sammy Haggar and Rick Springfield. Cheers.

Don Papa Small Batch rum
Don Papa Small Batch review posted 3 months ago by Heliski Agent (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 13 ratings

Hardly touched. Not even sure I'd make a cuba libre with this one. How is it on stains?

Plantation XO 20th Anniversary rum
Plantation XO 20th Anniversary review posted 3 months ago by Heliski Agent (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 13 ratings

Love it. Rich and robust. May be my favorite so far.

The Salford Rum Company Spiced rum
The Salford Rum Company Spiced review posted 3 months ago by JRoberts95 🇪🇸 | 55 ratings

Have tried several spiced rums from smaller U.K. distilleries, this is definitely up there. Nice colour and smell, does feel very artificially sweet at times, but a has a great flavour. Would recommend to to anyone looking for a U.K. rum. Bottle is a belter as well

Plantation Barbados Grande Reserve rum
Plantation Barbados Grande Reserve review posted 3 months ago by Administrator 🇸🇰 | 40 ratings

Not bad. The taste is dry with a hint of oak, not very sweet and a little bit like orange peels. Maybe it is better for mixed drinks. Light amber color.
Bottle is classic Plantation style, very nice with the cork.

Rum&Cane Central America XO Rum 6-Year rum
Rum&Cane Central America XO Rum 6-Year review posted 3 months ago by Bonandy 🇵🇱 | 116 ratings

Another bottle of Rum & Cane. A blend of rums from Guatemala and Nicaragua. Light amber color. Slightly sweet. Toffee and vanilla aroma. Perceptible alcohol strength 43%

Don Papa Baroko 3-Year rum
Don Papa Baroko 3-Year review posted 3 months ago by LUKAŽIGA 🇸🇮 | 263 ratings

6,9:The nose is very sweet, orange and vanilla. Like an oriental confection, the rum caresses the nostrils with a pinch of powdered sugar. One might think of a strawberry- or rosewater-flavored Turkish delight. The candied orange peel still contains some of its slightly bitter oil, which adds a little more depth.
Aeration confirms and reinforces the sensation of roundness. The candy sugar is melted and takes on the air of barley sugar. It's also reminiscent of the first bite of strawberry gum.
7:The palate is soft, fluid and quite sweet. The confectionery and bubblegum ambience remains, though one might have expected a stickier texture. The vanilla glides slowly over the tongue, the orange is in tune and forgets any hint of bitterness. On the other hand, a slight spicy, peppery note lifts the whole.
6,2:The finish is very sweet, with strawberry, banana and orange in confectionery form.

Plantation Xaymaca Special Dry rum
Plantation Xaymaca Special Dry review posted 3 months ago by Michael Norell 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

...than this rum. I can hardly believe there could be such a variation in ratings as on this rum, and maybe, just maybe it is like cilantro? Just genetically, perhaps some of us are wired to taste something grizzly where others taste something delightful. But I can honestly say I've never tasted any rum so "medicinal" as this. I have had good-tasting Plantation Rum in the past (I don't remember which variation), but this Xaymaca is truly awful to my own taste-buds.

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...