Loading...

Holmes Cay Reunion Island Grand Arome rum
Holmes Cay Reunion Island Grand Arome review posted 2 months ago by TheJayHawk 🇺🇸 | 104 ratings

Aroma - rotten pork followed by leather, moldy lime peel, and nail polish remover

Taste - salted pork followed by leather, dried tobacco leaf, and a charcoal finish

Holmes Cay Reunion Island rum
Holmes Cay Reunion Island review posted 2 months ago by TheJayHawk 🇺🇸 | 104 ratings

Aroma - spoiled pork followed by fresh tomatoes, nail polish remover, and salt water

Taste - salted French fries followed by pork, charcoal, and a bitter sugarcane finish

Kaniche Perfeccion rum
Kaniche Perfeccion review posted 2 months ago by Guilljea 🇺🇸 | 29 ratings

Just after opening the bottle, the smell from the cork and bottle was very present, it's tropical and definitively barrel smell.
It's very smooth, sweetness and dried fruit come over giving a fantastic taste.


Blackadder 1998 Raw Cask Finest Guadeloupe Belvedere Bellevue 17-Year rum

8,8:On the nose, the first notes are dried fruits, then out of nowhere arise tropical fruits with passion fruit leading the gang. It is very round. Nuttiness is around later, when aired, with some medicinal notes, grapes/sweet wine, sherry notes, becomes spicy, roasted, dry. Agricole notes with some smokiness are here now, with leathery/tobacco after well rested.
8,6:On the palate, we cannot miss agricole, volcanique pedigree and spiciness that we are hold on, dried fruits come out of this first agricole/spicy cloudy skies, are juicy with nice grapes and red fruits. They are sweet like very fine sweet wine. Roasted comes by to say hello with smokiness and some drieness, bitterness and orange peel and is still very round. Tropical fruits are here, but a bit hidden. Well confectionery has been waiting till the end to show up and nougat!
9:The finish is very long, a bit sweet, agricole notes stay. It becomes creamy, buttery and toasted with tropical/dried fruits, with minimal drieness.

Chairman’s Reserve Original Gold Ltd.Ed. by Llewellyn Xavier 5-Year rum

7,7:On the nose, it feels like a dry and woody rum, with lots of tropical fruits, a bit estery, dried fruits. The American oak barrel having left its mark. Aromas of tobacco and vanilla are also present. The whole is light, however and gives off a certain freshness.
7,7:On the palate, we confirm that it is not sweet at all and is quite dry. We feel nice tropical fruits, dried fruits, some saltiness. It is the woodiness that takes over after a while.
7,3:The finish is quite long, dry and dominated by dried fruits, vanilla and tobacco.

Appleton Estate Rare Casks 12-Year rum
Appleton Estate Rare Casks 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by dakthor 🇺🇸 | 11 ratings

Just like other Appleton products, they are Jamaican rums with less emphasis on the funk. The 12 year follows in this trend and is a great sipping rum for the price. There is some funk, but a much more an emphasis on vanilla, caramel, and slight oak notes.

Appleton Estate Signature rum
Appleton Estate Signature review posted 2 months ago by dakthor 🇺🇸 | 11 ratings

Simple, buttery, and slightly funky. Appleton signature is a great way to start getting into Jamaican flavors without something super funky. There’s still the overripe fruits and esters, but it’s much more tamed down than most other options.

Ten to One Caribbean White Rum rum
Ten to One Caribbean White Rum review posted 2 months ago by leobarnsphd 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

I only use it as a mixer but I love it. Blends well, has some character but doesn't stand out. So it plays well with other ingredients and flavor profiles.

Chairman’s Reserve White 2-3 Years rum
Chairman’s Reserve White 2-3 Years review posted 2 months ago by leobarnsphd 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

Take this review with a grain of salt the size of Gibraltar... this is my favorite rum for daiquiris. Clear, clean, crisp and bright. Just what I want in an ice cold daiquiri. Crushable. Good APV without any funk or harshness.

Here is my conundrum, I know the bottle I had was Chairman's Reserve.... but the age 2-3 is in question. So your rum mileage may vary.

Denizen 5-Year rum
Denizen 5-Year review posted 2 months ago by leobarnsphd 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

This is a solid daiquiri choice. Crisp. Clean. Crushable. I would not drink it near, but it works well with sugar and lime. Not overpowering.

Zafra Master Reserve 21 rum
Zafra Master Reserve 21 review posted 2 months ago by F.Sellera 🇧🇷 | 31 ratings

Smooth Rum ; very delicate
Lots os flavors ; mix of bananas / vanilla and smoke
Sweet but not too much
Complex and Excellent Afterburn

Vizcaya VXOP 21 rum
Vizcaya VXOP 21 review posted 2 months ago by CSG 🇺🇸 | 46 ratings

Just a bit of extra funk, so not a perfect 10 for me. But definitely a sipper, good mouthfeel, and sweet but not artificially or overdone.

El Dorado 12-Year rum
El Dorado 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by F.Sellera 🇧🇷 | 31 ratings

Good Rum smooth but ED much better both sweet Guyana

Diplomatico Selección de Familia rum
Diplomatico Selección de Familia review posted 2 months ago by F.Sellera 🇧🇷 | 31 ratings

43% sharper than Reserva Exclusiva
Simply amazing
One of my “must have”

Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva rum
Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva review posted 2 months ago by Sirena Rum 🇺🇸 | 1 rating

Dark caramel color, smell a little sweet and you will taste at end. Tó sugary taste for me.

Myers's Single Barrel Select rum
Myers's Single Barrel Select review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

This is a good rum. It's super smooth and the barrel has mellowed thisbone out.

Foursquare 2009 Equipoise ECS Mark XXV 14-Year rum
Foursquare 2009 Equipoise ECS Mark XXV 14-Year review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

Slow sipper. Pretty heavy burn on this one. It's quite nice.

Clement XO Hors d'Age 6-Year rum
Clement XO Hors d'Age 6-Year review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

Great sipper. No burn, sweet, and sort of funky. Would go well in a Mai Tai.

Izalco 10-Year rum
Izalco 10-Year review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

This is a good sipper. No burn and sort of sweet. It's very good.

Legendario Elixir de Cuba 7-Year rum
Legendario Elixir de Cuba 7-Year review posted 2 months ago by Deadfame 🇸🇰 | 78 ratings

Strasna apatieka. Vona to jak sirup od kasla-aj to tak chuti.
Lepihuba, nedivim sa ze to nemozu ani volat rum.
Bol to darcek tak sme to skusili a rozkopalo nas jak zahradku.

Transcontinental Rum Line Mauritius 3-Year rum
Transcontinental Rum Line Mauritius 3-Year review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

This, like most Transcontinental rums, is really good. Burn on the nose but very smooth. Slight funk makes this one stand out. Maybe some cherry, a little banana, and some caramel.

Denizen Merchants Reserve 8-Year rum
Denizen Merchants Reserve 8-Year review posted 2 months ago by abrarey 🇺🇸 | 69 ratings

This rum has earned a reputation for being a tasty addition to tiki cocktails, but I think it also holds its own when enjoyed neat. While it may not boast the same prestige as a high-end rum, it's still a solid choice that won't break the bank. Its flavor profile is complex and interesting, with a hint of funk that's characteristic of Jamaican rums. At this price point, I think it's definitely worth keeping on hand in your bar.

Ron Zacapa 23 Solera rum
Ron Zacapa 23 Solera review posted 2 months ago by The Sipping Pirate 🇳🇱 | 84 ratings

On the nose it smells like diplomatico but a bit leathery with a hint of alcohol. However, the taste is burnt sugar and the burn sets in immediately. When it goes down it burns less but for me this is not a sipper, more a mixer for cocktails.

Plantation Original Dark Trinidad rum
Plantation Original Dark Trinidad review posted 2 months ago by leobarnsphd 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

I love to mix this into mai tais and other tiki drinks. It's tasty but not overpowering. It's unique but not "acquired taste." For the price it punches well above its weight class.

Bacardi Superior rum
Bacardi Superior review posted 2 months ago by leobarnsphd 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

You dont know what you don't know. We all start out here. We have in a drink and think all rum is rum. This is the Bud Light of rums. Easy to get. Mixes ok into generic cocktails. Most won't complain but nobody will rave either. But that's it. Gets the job done but it's just not good.

Holmes Cay Reunion Island Grand Arome rum
Holmes Cay Reunion Island Grand Arome review posted 2 months ago by TheJayHawk 🇺🇸 | 104 ratings

Aroma - rotten pork followed by leather, moldy lime peel, and nail polish remover

Taste - salted pork followed by leather, dried tobacco leaf, and a charcoal finish

Holmes Cay Reunion Island rum
Holmes Cay Reunion Island review posted 2 months ago by TheJayHawk 🇺🇸 | 104 ratings

Aroma - spoiled pork followed by fresh tomatoes, nail polish remover, and salt water

Taste - salted French fries followed by pork, charcoal, and a bitter sugarcane finish

Kaniche Perfeccion rum
Kaniche Perfeccion review posted 2 months ago by Guilljea 🇺🇸 | 29 ratings

Just after opening the bottle, the smell from the cork and bottle was very present, it's tropical and definitively barrel smell.
It's very smooth, sweetness and dried fruit come over giving a fantastic taste.


Blackadder 1998 Raw Cask Finest Guadeloupe Belvedere Bellevue 17-Year rum

8,8:On the nose, the first notes are dried fruits, then out of nowhere arise tropical fruits with passion fruit leading the gang. It is very round. Nuttiness is around later, when aired, with some medicinal notes, grapes/sweet wine, sherry notes, becomes spicy, roasted, dry. Agricole notes with some smokiness are here now, with leathery/tobacco after well rested.
8,6:On the palate, we cannot miss agricole, volcanique pedigree and spiciness that we are hold on, dried fruits come out of this first agricole/spicy cloudy skies, are juicy with nice grapes and red fruits. They are sweet like very fine sweet wine. Roasted comes by to say hello with smokiness and some drieness, bitterness and orange peel and is still very round. Tropical fruits are here, but a bit hidden. Well confectionery has been waiting till the end to show up and nougat!
9:The finish is very long, a bit sweet, agricole notes stay. It becomes creamy, buttery and toasted with tropical/dried fruits, with minimal drieness.

Chairman’s Reserve Original Gold Ltd.Ed. by Llewellyn Xavier 5-Year rum

7,7:On the nose, it feels like a dry and woody rum, with lots of tropical fruits, a bit estery, dried fruits. The American oak barrel having left its mark. Aromas of tobacco and vanilla are also present. The whole is light, however and gives off a certain freshness.
7,7:On the palate, we confirm that it is not sweet at all and is quite dry. We feel nice tropical fruits, dried fruits, some saltiness. It is the woodiness that takes over after a while.
7,3:The finish is quite long, dry and dominated by dried fruits, vanilla and tobacco.

Appleton Estate Rare Casks 12-Year rum
Appleton Estate Rare Casks 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by dakthor 🇺🇸 | 11 ratings

Just like other Appleton products, they are Jamaican rums with less emphasis on the funk. The 12 year follows in this trend and is a great sipping rum for the price. There is some funk, but a much more an emphasis on vanilla, caramel, and slight oak notes.

Appleton Estate Signature rum
Appleton Estate Signature review posted 2 months ago by dakthor 🇺🇸 | 11 ratings

Simple, buttery, and slightly funky. Appleton signature is a great way to start getting into Jamaican flavors without something super funky. There’s still the overripe fruits and esters, but it’s much more tamed down than most other options.

Ten to One Caribbean White Rum rum
Ten to One Caribbean White Rum review posted 2 months ago by leobarnsphd 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

I only use it as a mixer but I love it. Blends well, has some character but doesn't stand out. So it plays well with other ingredients and flavor profiles.

Chairman’s Reserve White 2-3 Years rum
Chairman’s Reserve White 2-3 Years review posted 2 months ago by leobarnsphd 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

Take this review with a grain of salt the size of Gibraltar... this is my favorite rum for daiquiris. Clear, clean, crisp and bright. Just what I want in an ice cold daiquiri. Crushable. Good APV without any funk or harshness.

Here is my conundrum, I know the bottle I had was Chairman's Reserve.... but the age 2-3 is in question. So your rum mileage may vary.

Denizen 5-Year rum
Denizen 5-Year review posted 2 months ago by leobarnsphd 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

This is a solid daiquiri choice. Crisp. Clean. Crushable. I would not drink it near, but it works well with sugar and lime. Not overpowering.

Zafra Master Reserve 21 rum
Zafra Master Reserve 21 review posted 2 months ago by F.Sellera 🇧🇷 | 31 ratings

Smooth Rum ; very delicate
Lots os flavors ; mix of bananas / vanilla and smoke
Sweet but not too much
Complex and Excellent Afterburn

Vizcaya VXOP 21 rum
Vizcaya VXOP 21 review posted 2 months ago by CSG 🇺🇸 | 46 ratings

Just a bit of extra funk, so not a perfect 10 for me. But definitely a sipper, good mouthfeel, and sweet but not artificially or overdone.

El Dorado 12-Year rum
El Dorado 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by F.Sellera 🇧🇷 | 31 ratings

Good Rum smooth but ED much better both sweet Guyana

Diplomatico Selección de Familia rum
Diplomatico Selección de Familia review posted 2 months ago by F.Sellera 🇧🇷 | 31 ratings

43% sharper than Reserva Exclusiva
Simply amazing
One of my “must have”

Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva rum
Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva review posted 2 months ago by Sirena Rum 🇺🇸 | 1 rating

Dark caramel color, smell a little sweet and you will taste at end. Tó sugary taste for me.

Myers's Single Barrel Select rum
Myers's Single Barrel Select review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

This is a good rum. It's super smooth and the barrel has mellowed thisbone out.

Foursquare 2009 Equipoise ECS Mark XXV 14-Year rum
Foursquare 2009 Equipoise ECS Mark XXV 14-Year review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

Slow sipper. Pretty heavy burn on this one. It's quite nice.

Clement XO Hors d'Age 6-Year rum
Clement XO Hors d'Age 6-Year review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

Great sipper. No burn, sweet, and sort of funky. Would go well in a Mai Tai.

Izalco 10-Year rum
Izalco 10-Year review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

This is a good sipper. No burn and sort of sweet. It's very good.

Legendario Elixir de Cuba 7-Year rum
Legendario Elixir de Cuba 7-Year review posted 2 months ago by Deadfame 🇸🇰 | 78 ratings

Strasna apatieka. Vona to jak sirup od kasla-aj to tak chuti.
Lepihuba, nedivim sa ze to nemozu ani volat rum.
Bol to darcek tak sme to skusili a rozkopalo nas jak zahradku.

Transcontinental Rum Line Mauritius 3-Year rum
Transcontinental Rum Line Mauritius 3-Year review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

This, like most Transcontinental rums, is really good. Burn on the nose but very smooth. Slight funk makes this one stand out. Maybe some cherry, a little banana, and some caramel.

Denizen Merchants Reserve 8-Year rum
Denizen Merchants Reserve 8-Year review posted 2 months ago by abrarey 🇺🇸 | 69 ratings

This rum has earned a reputation for being a tasty addition to tiki cocktails, but I think it also holds its own when enjoyed neat. While it may not boast the same prestige as a high-end rum, it's still a solid choice that won't break the bank. Its flavor profile is complex and interesting, with a hint of funk that's characteristic of Jamaican rums. At this price point, I think it's definitely worth keeping on hand in your bar.

Ron Zacapa 23 Solera rum
Ron Zacapa 23 Solera review posted 2 months ago by The Sipping Pirate 🇳🇱 | 84 ratings

On the nose it smells like diplomatico but a bit leathery with a hint of alcohol. However, the taste is burnt sugar and the burn sets in immediately. When it goes down it burns less but for me this is not a sipper, more a mixer for cocktails.

Plantation Original Dark Trinidad rum
Plantation Original Dark Trinidad review posted 2 months ago by leobarnsphd 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

I love to mix this into mai tais and other tiki drinks. It's tasty but not overpowering. It's unique but not "acquired taste." For the price it punches well above its weight class.

Bacardi Superior rum
Bacardi Superior review posted 2 months ago by leobarnsphd 🇺🇸 | 6 ratings

You dont know what you don't know. We all start out here. We have in a drink and think all rum is rum. This is the Bud Light of rums. Easy to get. Mixes ok into generic cocktails. Most won't complain but nobody will rave either. But that's it. Gets the job done but it's just not good.

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...