Loading...

Barcelo Blanco rum
Barcelo Blanco review posted 2 months ago by JKNitro 🇫🇮 | 100 ratings

Clear as water in color, ofcause. Ethanol and sweet notes of banana on the nose, some herbs also. Quite sweet at start, ethanol kicks in too warming the chest. Moderate notes of banana, peach and some spices on palate. I tried with coke too: ethanol taste disapperars totally, nice flavor added to coke. If one likes a bit drier, I would recommend Bacardi Blanco over this, but my liking of sweeter rums, this is quite good. Dare I say, in some sircumstances this goes even as is?

Companero Panama Extra Añejo 12-Year rum
Companero Panama Extra Añejo 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by LUKAŽIGA 🇸🇮 | 255 ratings

6,8:On the nose the attack of chocolate is very impressive, it is sweet, alcoholic, not dry. Chocolate lovers can get their heaven in this rum.Tones of sweet cocoa powder all around us. Orange peel, vanilla and spice are overwhelmed by the chocolate. Aeration brings out more creamy chocolate, butterscotch, more bitterness and quite strong metallic notes, even meaty?!
7:On the palate, heavy bodied sweet rum, syrupy, full of chocolate attacks our tasting buds with some nice orange peel as counterbalance.Under the chocolate, we find lots of butterscotch sweetness, caramel, sweet spices, hints of vanilla and some oak.
7:The finish is long filled with sweet chocolate, a bit bitter and butterscotch, iodine and is a bit citrusy.

Negrita Spiced Golden rum
Negrita Spiced Golden review posted 2 months ago by Ravanagh (PREMIUM) 🇦🇺 | 31 ratings

Cheap whisky is actually drinkable, but the rule doesn’t seem to hold for rum.


Captain Morgan Black Spiced rum
Captain Morgan Black Spiced review posted 2 months ago by Greentwig 🇺🇸 | 2 ratings

Was gifted this bottle and sat and collected dust for many years. Popped it open to make classic daiquiris, wasn't great, wasn't terrible.

Rhum JM VSOP 4-Year rum
Rhum JM VSOP 4-Year review posted at Zogg's Raw Bar & Grill 2 months ago by Solidfunk 🇺🇸 | 51 ratings

Decent dose of cognac here and comes around nice. I get potpourri, tanned leather and booze. Dark clear copper pour. Spicy booze tinge sticks with you, not much sweetness here.

Dictador Solera Ultra Premium Reserve 12-Year rum
Dictador Solera Ultra Premium Reserve 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by Ravanagh (PREMIUM) 🇦🇺 | 31 ratings

Look, I like it. There are probably better Caribbean rums out there … I doubt I’ll go back to this; but it’s well worth supporting the beacon of Western success stories in an otherwise chaotic region. Cheers to that!

El Dorado 12-Year rum
El Dorado 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by Ravanagh (PREMIUM) 🇦🇺 | 31 ratings

Shame we lost Guyana but we’ve still got the rum and that’s the main thing. This is everso smooth — delectable!

Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva rum
Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva review posted 2 months ago by Ravanagh (PREMIUM) 🇦🇺 | 31 ratings

It’s a great Caribbean rum for a completist to try. Smooth and flavoursome with subtle spice.

Saint James Imperial Blanc 40 rum
Saint James Imperial Blanc 40 review posted 2 months ago by AlexMo 🇷🇺 | 208 ratings

Attractive design, best in class. Not quite pure alcohol, which makes the taste more interesting and softened, but aftertaste is rough, stupefies the head for a long time. Suitable for ti punch.

Wagemut Edition 2023 Barbados Foursquare 16-Year rum
Wagemut Edition 2023 Barbados Foursquare 16-Year review posted 2 months ago by Jacko 🇳🇱 | 35 ratings

Tasted like an angel passing on your tongie.. This is truly amazing..

WAREMUT does the thing

Plantation Xaymaca Special Dry rum
Plantation Xaymaca Special Dry review posted 2 months ago by Jacko 🇳🇱 | 35 ratings

Ok ok.. This one has no sweet stuff inserted. The sweetness comes from the rum itself.
To me. It had a nice Esters head. Very nice

Savanna Lontan 57 rum
Savanna Lontan 57 review posted 2 months ago by 20h20 🇬🇧 | 4 ratings

When I first read review mentioning brine I was like why the hell would I drink this, yet it makes sense, and is amazing even though it's such an alien taste

The Coronation Rum 2023 Buckingham Palace rum
The Coronation Rum 2023 Buckingham Palace review posted 2 months ago by Rene Rum (PREMIUM) 🇨🇭 | 548 ratings

Schönes orangefarbenes Bernstein im Glas.
In der Nase frisch und fruchtig. Diverse tropische Früchte überraschen immer wieder aufs Neue. Karamelltöne, Hölzer und harzige Noten sitzen in der zweiten Reihe. Blumen und Gräser welken langsam in der Ferne.
Am Gaumen weich und geschmeidig. Frische Fruchtbrote mit ein wenig Karamell und Vanille zergehen sanft auf der Zunge. Hölzer und Tannine sind dezent im Hintergrund.
Im Abgang kurz und bündig. Holz und Karamell verschwindet zuerst, die Fruchtaromen bleiben etwas länger.
Ein durchaus eleganter und sehr leichter Navy Rum, mir fehlt aber eine gewisse tiefe und schwere. Die 40 % machen das Ganze auch nicht zu mehr Navy Style. Für Landratten, Einsteiger, Leichtmatrosen und das gemeine Volk, sicherlich nicht für den König.
Für meine 9. Rumrunde mit dem Thema Navy Rum.

Beautiful orange amber in the glass.
Fresh and fruity on the nose. Various tropical fruits surprise again and again. Caramel tones, woods and resinous notes sit in the second row. Flowers and grasses slowly wilt in the distance.
Soft and supple on the palate. Fresh fruit breads with a little caramel and vanilla melt gently on the tongue. Wood and tannins are discreetly in the background.
The finish is short and sweet. Wood and caramel disappear first, the fruit flavors remain a little longer.
A thoroughly elegant and very light navy rum, but I miss a certain depth and weight. The 40% doesn't make the whole thing any more navy style. For landlubbers, beginners, light sailors and the common people, certainly not for the king.
For my 9th rum round with the theme Navy Rum.

Kraken Black Spiced rum
Kraken Black Spiced review posted 2 months ago by Greentwig 🇺🇸 | 2 ratings

So I got this rum recently, I tried a tiny bottle of it and thought it was smooth and sweet. It's got heavy vanilla and caramel notes. Not terriblr in a mixed drink or on its own if you enjoy sweet things.

Canerock Spiced & Flavored rum
Canerock Spiced & Flavored review posted 2 months ago by Jara 🇨🇿 | 387 ratings

Vůně: Hlavně karamel, lihovější, lékárna, ovocný drops
Chuť: Sladká, léčivé byliny, pepř, nahnilá tráva(třtina), karamel.
Dochuť: Lehounce sudová, bylinně nahořklá
Jakési na rum neobvyklé, much spice, pořád to evokuje lékárnu.
Nesedl mi, jako Rumbullion.
6,0/10

Wagemut PX Cask Barbados 5-Year rum
Wagemut PX Cask Barbados 5-Year review posted 2 months ago by nilseckhardt 🇩🇪 | 1 rating

Before we get to the actual evaluation, a few ambiguities need to be clarified, which @Chamarelo has already addressed:
1. the rum from Foursquare was distilled in Barbados (pot & column still) and aged there for 10! (not 5) years in ex-bourbon barrels.
2. the subsequent maturation in PX sherry casks takes place in Germany and lasts at least 3 months. (Strictly speaking, the maturation takes place in former German red wine casks filled with fresh PX sherry from Xerez).

But now to the actual assessment:
-On the nose, the spicy notes of the still relatively young Barbados rum are particularly evident, but the sherry influence can also be detected on the nose: This is expressed through hints of raisins and figs.
-On the tongue, you are surprised by a surprising complexity. The distillate is smooth on the palate and never burns. In the finish, the aftertaste of the PX Cask is quite long and is characterized by a vanilla note.

In conclusion, this rum is the perfect choice to AUTHENTICALLY introduce the rum world to beginners. The sherry influence makes the rum world accessible to beginners.
My criticism is, however, related to ALL sherry maturations: The influence of the sherry gives the impression that the rum has a complexity that the distillate itself does not usually provide.The consumer should always be aware that these sweet, fruity aromas do not come from the rum itself, but from the influence of the sweet wine. If you are aware of this and simply enjoy drinking PX rums, even experienced rum drinkers can have a lot of fun with this rum. For 39.90 euros, a clear recommendation to buy!

Worthy Park 109 rum
Worthy Park 109 review posted 2 months ago by JarkkoKoo (PREMIUM) 🇫🇮 | 46 ratings

Nice looking, stylish bottle. The rum is really dark, must have colors added. Smells like syrup, most likely molasses but no banana aromas that I would have liked. The flavor has a kick to it. It's not only the ABV but the general feel of it. Tastes like burnt sugar and coffee.

Alleyne Arthur's Special Barbados rum
Alleyne Arthur's Special Barbados review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

This might be the best $15 rum I've had in a long time. Made by Foursquare does not hurt either.

Pusser's British Navy Blue Label ABV42 3-Year rum
Pusser's British Navy Blue Label ABV42 3-Year review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

This rum is just an standard in the rum world. You can't make a Painkiller without it. Currently enjoying just sipping on this for Black Tot Day.

Kuna Panama Aged rum
Kuna Panama Aged review posted 2 months ago by DesT9656 🇨🇦 | 134 ratings

ending on a high note with my favorite country - Panama. was not familiar with the brand but enjoying this pour in a big way. Where has it been all my life? Price on the shelf was not that objectionable and perceived as a decent value. Good nose, great taste. Smooooooth and I really enjoyed the finish......of the rum and a great evening of tasting. Cheers to all and to all a good night!

Kraken Black Spiced rum
Kraken Black Spiced review posted 2 months ago by -_PAIN_- 🇵🇱 | 1 rating

I love strong alcohols, and kraken made me love rum. It has smooth start, little bit of vanilla flavor and harsh finish that is too much for many. I know it's not the "real rum" beacuse it's spiced, but imo it's the best spiced rum available for the price, far better than capitan morgan or bacardi.

English Harbour 10-Year rum
English Harbour 10-Year review posted 2 months ago by DesT9656 🇨🇦 | 134 ratings

at a tasting and expected this to be on the better side of good but this is rediculously delicious. a bit weak on the nose but instantly forgiven with taste in the most impressive way. expected a bit more burn but this is one of those rums that makes the search worth the effort. a bit on the expensive side and looking forward to trying some rums not available in Canada that are mentioned here. Still impressive and hopefully everyone gets the opportunity to sample.. cheers.

Santisima Trinidad de Cuba 15-Year rum
Santisima Trinidad de Cuba 15-Year review posted 2 months ago by DesT9656 🇨🇦 | 134 ratings

I was looking forward to an Havana club alternative in Alberta. this is wonderful but about 50% more expensive than the selection de maestros. same great smell and taste - honestly don't know who would win a blind taste test. this had a cleaner smell and taste than HC but the HC taste was more complex and "adult". finish was better with HC also. regardless - both are great sippers and enjoy them for a different reasons. HC wins on taste and overall value.

Kirkland Port Cask Finished Panama 12-Year rum
Kirkland Port Cask Finished Panama 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by xrodriguez 🇺🇸 | 52 ratings

Very surprised how much I liked this. Reasonably priced sipper. Definitely a keeper.

Barcelo Dorado rum
Barcelo Dorado review posted 2 months ago by xrodriguez 🇺🇸 | 52 ratings

Was looking for a price point mixer. This is not bad. Would definitely buy again.

Barcelo Blanco rum
Barcelo Blanco review posted 2 months ago by JKNitro 🇫🇮 | 100 ratings

Clear as water in color, ofcause. Ethanol and sweet notes of banana on the nose, some herbs also. Quite sweet at start, ethanol kicks in too warming the chest. Moderate notes of banana, peach and some spices on palate. I tried with coke too: ethanol taste disapperars totally, nice flavor added to coke. If one likes a bit drier, I would recommend Bacardi Blanco over this, but my liking of sweeter rums, this is quite good. Dare I say, in some sircumstances this goes even as is?

Companero Panama Extra Añejo 12-Year rum
Companero Panama Extra Añejo 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by LUKAŽIGA 🇸🇮 | 255 ratings

6,8:On the nose the attack of chocolate is very impressive, it is sweet, alcoholic, not dry. Chocolate lovers can get their heaven in this rum.Tones of sweet cocoa powder all around us. Orange peel, vanilla and spice are overwhelmed by the chocolate. Aeration brings out more creamy chocolate, butterscotch, more bitterness and quite strong metallic notes, even meaty?!
7:On the palate, heavy bodied sweet rum, syrupy, full of chocolate attacks our tasting buds with some nice orange peel as counterbalance.Under the chocolate, we find lots of butterscotch sweetness, caramel, sweet spices, hints of vanilla and some oak.
7:The finish is long filled with sweet chocolate, a bit bitter and butterscotch, iodine and is a bit citrusy.

Negrita Spiced Golden rum
Negrita Spiced Golden review posted 2 months ago by Ravanagh (PREMIUM) 🇦🇺 | 31 ratings

Cheap whisky is actually drinkable, but the rule doesn’t seem to hold for rum.


Captain Morgan Black Spiced rum
Captain Morgan Black Spiced review posted 2 months ago by Greentwig 🇺🇸 | 2 ratings

Was gifted this bottle and sat and collected dust for many years. Popped it open to make classic daiquiris, wasn't great, wasn't terrible.

Rhum JM VSOP 4-Year rum
Rhum JM VSOP 4-Year review posted at Zogg's Raw Bar & Grill 2 months ago by Solidfunk 🇺🇸 | 51 ratings

Decent dose of cognac here and comes around nice. I get potpourri, tanned leather and booze. Dark clear copper pour. Spicy booze tinge sticks with you, not much sweetness here.

Dictador Solera Ultra Premium Reserve 12-Year rum
Dictador Solera Ultra Premium Reserve 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by Ravanagh (PREMIUM) 🇦🇺 | 31 ratings

Look, I like it. There are probably better Caribbean rums out there … I doubt I’ll go back to this; but it’s well worth supporting the beacon of Western success stories in an otherwise chaotic region. Cheers to that!

El Dorado 12-Year rum
El Dorado 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by Ravanagh (PREMIUM) 🇦🇺 | 31 ratings

Shame we lost Guyana but we’ve still got the rum and that’s the main thing. This is everso smooth — delectable!

Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva rum
Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva review posted 2 months ago by Ravanagh (PREMIUM) 🇦🇺 | 31 ratings

It’s a great Caribbean rum for a completist to try. Smooth and flavoursome with subtle spice.

Saint James Imperial Blanc 40 rum
Saint James Imperial Blanc 40 review posted 2 months ago by AlexMo 🇷🇺 | 208 ratings

Attractive design, best in class. Not quite pure alcohol, which makes the taste more interesting and softened, but aftertaste is rough, stupefies the head for a long time. Suitable for ti punch.

Wagemut Edition 2023 Barbados Foursquare 16-Year rum
Wagemut Edition 2023 Barbados Foursquare 16-Year review posted 2 months ago by Jacko 🇳🇱 | 35 ratings

Tasted like an angel passing on your tongie.. This is truly amazing..

WAREMUT does the thing

Plantation Xaymaca Special Dry rum
Plantation Xaymaca Special Dry review posted 2 months ago by Jacko 🇳🇱 | 35 ratings

Ok ok.. This one has no sweet stuff inserted. The sweetness comes from the rum itself.
To me. It had a nice Esters head. Very nice

Savanna Lontan 57 rum
Savanna Lontan 57 review posted 2 months ago by 20h20 🇬🇧 | 4 ratings

When I first read review mentioning brine I was like why the hell would I drink this, yet it makes sense, and is amazing even though it's such an alien taste

The Coronation Rum 2023 Buckingham Palace rum
The Coronation Rum 2023 Buckingham Palace review posted 2 months ago by Rene Rum (PREMIUM) 🇨🇭 | 548 ratings

Schönes orangefarbenes Bernstein im Glas.
In der Nase frisch und fruchtig. Diverse tropische Früchte überraschen immer wieder aufs Neue. Karamelltöne, Hölzer und harzige Noten sitzen in der zweiten Reihe. Blumen und Gräser welken langsam in der Ferne.
Am Gaumen weich und geschmeidig. Frische Fruchtbrote mit ein wenig Karamell und Vanille zergehen sanft auf der Zunge. Hölzer und Tannine sind dezent im Hintergrund.
Im Abgang kurz und bündig. Holz und Karamell verschwindet zuerst, die Fruchtaromen bleiben etwas länger.
Ein durchaus eleganter und sehr leichter Navy Rum, mir fehlt aber eine gewisse tiefe und schwere. Die 40 % machen das Ganze auch nicht zu mehr Navy Style. Für Landratten, Einsteiger, Leichtmatrosen und das gemeine Volk, sicherlich nicht für den König.
Für meine 9. Rumrunde mit dem Thema Navy Rum.

Beautiful orange amber in the glass.
Fresh and fruity on the nose. Various tropical fruits surprise again and again. Caramel tones, woods and resinous notes sit in the second row. Flowers and grasses slowly wilt in the distance.
Soft and supple on the palate. Fresh fruit breads with a little caramel and vanilla melt gently on the tongue. Wood and tannins are discreetly in the background.
The finish is short and sweet. Wood and caramel disappear first, the fruit flavors remain a little longer.
A thoroughly elegant and very light navy rum, but I miss a certain depth and weight. The 40% doesn't make the whole thing any more navy style. For landlubbers, beginners, light sailors and the common people, certainly not for the king.
For my 9th rum round with the theme Navy Rum.

Kraken Black Spiced rum
Kraken Black Spiced review posted 2 months ago by Greentwig 🇺🇸 | 2 ratings

So I got this rum recently, I tried a tiny bottle of it and thought it was smooth and sweet. It's got heavy vanilla and caramel notes. Not terriblr in a mixed drink or on its own if you enjoy sweet things.

Canerock Spiced & Flavored rum
Canerock Spiced & Flavored review posted 2 months ago by Jara 🇨🇿 | 387 ratings

Vůně: Hlavně karamel, lihovější, lékárna, ovocný drops
Chuť: Sladká, léčivé byliny, pepř, nahnilá tráva(třtina), karamel.
Dochuť: Lehounce sudová, bylinně nahořklá
Jakési na rum neobvyklé, much spice, pořád to evokuje lékárnu.
Nesedl mi, jako Rumbullion.
6,0/10

Wagemut PX Cask Barbados 5-Year rum
Wagemut PX Cask Barbados 5-Year review posted 2 months ago by nilseckhardt 🇩🇪 | 1 rating

Before we get to the actual evaluation, a few ambiguities need to be clarified, which @Chamarelo has already addressed:
1. the rum from Foursquare was distilled in Barbados (pot & column still) and aged there for 10! (not 5) years in ex-bourbon barrels.
2. the subsequent maturation in PX sherry casks takes place in Germany and lasts at least 3 months. (Strictly speaking, the maturation takes place in former German red wine casks filled with fresh PX sherry from Xerez).

But now to the actual assessment:
-On the nose, the spicy notes of the still relatively young Barbados rum are particularly evident, but the sherry influence can also be detected on the nose: This is expressed through hints of raisins and figs.
-On the tongue, you are surprised by a surprising complexity. The distillate is smooth on the palate and never burns. In the finish, the aftertaste of the PX Cask is quite long and is characterized by a vanilla note.

In conclusion, this rum is the perfect choice to AUTHENTICALLY introduce the rum world to beginners. The sherry influence makes the rum world accessible to beginners.
My criticism is, however, related to ALL sherry maturations: The influence of the sherry gives the impression that the rum has a complexity that the distillate itself does not usually provide.The consumer should always be aware that these sweet, fruity aromas do not come from the rum itself, but from the influence of the sweet wine. If you are aware of this and simply enjoy drinking PX rums, even experienced rum drinkers can have a lot of fun with this rum. For 39.90 euros, a clear recommendation to buy!

Worthy Park 109 rum
Worthy Park 109 review posted 2 months ago by JarkkoKoo (PREMIUM) 🇫🇮 | 46 ratings

Nice looking, stylish bottle. The rum is really dark, must have colors added. Smells like syrup, most likely molasses but no banana aromas that I would have liked. The flavor has a kick to it. It's not only the ABV but the general feel of it. Tastes like burnt sugar and coffee.

Alleyne Arthur's Special Barbados rum
Alleyne Arthur's Special Barbados review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

This might be the best $15 rum I've had in a long time. Made by Foursquare does not hurt either.

Pusser's British Navy Blue Label ABV42 3-Year rum
Pusser's British Navy Blue Label ABV42 3-Year review posted 2 months ago by Steven 🇺🇸 | 49 ratings

This rum is just an standard in the rum world. You can't make a Painkiller without it. Currently enjoying just sipping on this for Black Tot Day.

Kuna Panama Aged rum
Kuna Panama Aged review posted 2 months ago by DesT9656 🇨🇦 | 134 ratings

ending on a high note with my favorite country - Panama. was not familiar with the brand but enjoying this pour in a big way. Where has it been all my life? Price on the shelf was not that objectionable and perceived as a decent value. Good nose, great taste. Smooooooth and I really enjoyed the finish......of the rum and a great evening of tasting. Cheers to all and to all a good night!

Kraken Black Spiced rum
Kraken Black Spiced review posted 2 months ago by -_PAIN_- 🇵🇱 | 1 rating

I love strong alcohols, and kraken made me love rum. It has smooth start, little bit of vanilla flavor and harsh finish that is too much for many. I know it's not the "real rum" beacuse it's spiced, but imo it's the best spiced rum available for the price, far better than capitan morgan or bacardi.

English Harbour 10-Year rum
English Harbour 10-Year review posted 2 months ago by DesT9656 🇨🇦 | 134 ratings

at a tasting and expected this to be on the better side of good but this is rediculously delicious. a bit weak on the nose but instantly forgiven with taste in the most impressive way. expected a bit more burn but this is one of those rums that makes the search worth the effort. a bit on the expensive side and looking forward to trying some rums not available in Canada that are mentioned here. Still impressive and hopefully everyone gets the opportunity to sample.. cheers.

Santisima Trinidad de Cuba 15-Year rum
Santisima Trinidad de Cuba 15-Year review posted 2 months ago by DesT9656 🇨🇦 | 134 ratings

I was looking forward to an Havana club alternative in Alberta. this is wonderful but about 50% more expensive than the selection de maestros. same great smell and taste - honestly don't know who would win a blind taste test. this had a cleaner smell and taste than HC but the HC taste was more complex and "adult". finish was better with HC also. regardless - both are great sippers and enjoy them for a different reasons. HC wins on taste and overall value.

Kirkland Port Cask Finished Panama 12-Year rum
Kirkland Port Cask Finished Panama 12-Year review posted 2 months ago by xrodriguez 🇺🇸 | 52 ratings

Very surprised how much I liked this. Reasonably priced sipper. Definitely a keeper.

Barcelo Dorado rum
Barcelo Dorado review posted 2 months ago by xrodriguez 🇺🇸 | 52 ratings

Was looking for a price point mixer. This is not bad. Would definitely buy again.

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...